
(SBS 2004; alternative titles: Memories of Bali, Something Happened in Bali)
First, a big Ni Hao shout-out to all my chingus in dramaland (and a warning that what you are about to read may contain snippets of a newly discovered language I hereby dub KorChinGlish – trademark pending). Second, a happy wave to Thundie for allowing me a return trip to her blog. And finally, I’m back with a follow-up attempt to entertain you, with a K-drama review which I hope answers the age-old question everyone has been dying to know.
What the heck happened in Bali?
And why won’t anyone say anything about this drama other than the ominous “you should watch and find out.” Should you cue up the music of dread and ask your best friend to come over and watch with you, preferably with your eyes hidden behind your fingers? Heh, of course not, silly! [Unless your best friend happens to look EXACTLY like Lee Min Ho from Personal Taste, then the answer is a yesyesyesyesyes, and if I have to tell you why, you need a smack upside the head].
What Happened in Bali is a story about love. There, doesn’t that just calm you down considerably. You like dramas about love, right? [If you don’t, please exit stage left and keep walking – you’ll see the giant neon sign that says “Enter Here Ye All Who Have No Heart” and walk right on in - the Scarecrow from the Wizard of Oz, Stalin and the Stepmom from Brilliant Legacy will be waiting for you].
If you like dramas about love, and like even more dramas that treat you like an adult with a functioning brain, then have I got the drama for you! So strap on your seat belt, and let’s go for a Mr. Frog’s Wild Ride-esque trip through the deepest, darkest, recesses of “love” with a gang of strapping, young things.
Hey, wait a Lostie minute! On second thought, you may want to have your best friend on speed dial (even if he doesn’t look like Lee Min Ho, he still has some value). And a reminder to hold that cell phone tightly in your hand, because you may accidentally throw it at the screen. I don’t want to owe you a new cell phone (and/or a new screen).
Hey, K-dramas can buck convention, who woulda thunk it? (or better yet, let’s watch a K-drama throw convention under a bus and then stomp on it a few times to make sure it’s good and dead):
What Happened in Bali (“WHIB”) was a drama I decided to watch on a whim. I had not heard anything substantive about it, it was not recommended to me, and I had never seen any of the four leads in any drama prior to watching them in WHIB. I think I may have glanced a passing reference to WHIB in the blogosphere, and subconsciously stored this drama title away in my little pea brain.
Until one day I randomly decided to check out one episode. Ladies and gentlemen, checking out one episode of WHIB is like following the White Rabbit down the rabbit hole. Are you ready to have your worldview on K-dramas challenged, and perhaps changed irrevocably? If so, welcome to WHIB Wonderland, a place full of shiny pretty things with dark and dirty desires.

WHIB is a character drama that explores the very foundations of what many seminal K-romance melodramas have been built upon: the Cinderella story. WHIB strips the Cinderella story bare to look at social constructs that have been hidden away by the screenwriter in order to create the illusion of happily ever after.
WHIB asks you to make a judgment about whether a poor kind-hearted girl meeting a rich, eligible or successful man is akin to winning the lottery, i.e. hitting the jackpot of eternal happiness. Or is it really just a chance to play a round of Russian roulette.
Your judgment will be yours and yours alone. Some may share in your conclusion, others likely will not. But WHIB never once tells you what the right answer is, because there is little that is black and white in the drama. WHIB is draped completely in shades of gray. [If you like easy answers, I’ll be more than happy give you some, I like telling people what to think, some call it brainwashing, I like to think of it as doing the OPW].
WHIB merely tells you what happened, hence the extremely apropos title. You may scream “What the *&^% just happened?!?” when you reach the conclusion of the drama. But you’ll be faced with silence and either a TV or computer screen. Then you’ll sit back, knock down a few shots of soju, and maybe stagger here to the comments section of this review to vent (or ask me to hold your hand and brainwash you). I’ll be waiting for you.
These four kids are about to get bush-wacked and they don’t even know it:
WHIB stars Ha Ji Won as Lee Soo Jung, a hard-scrabble orphaned girl with a loser older brother. We first meet Soo Jung in the idyllic Shangri-la that is Bali, Indonesia. She’s working there as a tour guide, cobbling together enough money so that she can begin living a normal life. [Caveat, I make no judgment as to whether a tour guide in a vacation paradise is or is not a normal life, merely that Soo Jung wants to settle down, preferably back in her native Korea].

She’s neither a dreamer nor a hardened pragmatist. She lives day to day, and doesn’t dream that her life will change for the better other than through her own two hands. But she’s not (yet) bitter. She’s a decent person, and a refreshing change from the parade of innocent young female leads in dramas. You know, those paragons of virtue who are full of can-do spirit and an unending river of generosity and forgiveness. [Or as I like to think, a ride on It’s a Small World: B-oring, as opposed to a ride on Space Mountain: Wheeeee].
Street-wise and engaging Soo Jung is hired to be the tour guide for the world’s most awkward touring trio. Let’s meet the threesome, shall we?

So Ji Sub is Kang In Wook, a smart, handsome, ambitious young man climbing the corporate ladder. His rich college girlfriend, Park Ye Jin as Choi Young-joo, broke up with him because his poor birth made him unsuitable marriage material. In Wook has transferred to the Indonesia office to get away and move on. But said college girlfriend is not so sure she made the right choice now that she’s engaged to a rich second son of a corporate scion.

In a moment of rebellion, armed with a smidgeon of hope, Young-joo hightails it to Indonesia to maybe reconcile with In Wook. The uncertain couple travel to Bali for one last hurrah. [I like that, who says a girl can’t sow her wild oats before she gets leg-shackled in an arranged marriage – feminism means women can and should do the same crappy shit men can do].
And look who shows up to get the party (really) started, none other than the newly acquired fiancée himself. Jung Jae Min, played by Jo In Sung, has followed Young Joo to Bali out of a mixture of curiousity and boredom.

Young Joo is annoyed her churlish new fiancée has come to interrupt her secret getaway with her ex-boyfriend. Jae Min is amused he’s interjected himself into an awkward situation, though he’s not opposed to exercising some fiancée rights. And In Wook maintains a poker face (but since I can read So Ji Sub, let me tell you, he’s not happy that he has to meet the new fiancée and deal with ending things for good with his ex-girlfriend). Commence the three-way death glare staredown!

And lest we forget, little Soo Jung is driving the dysfunctional threesome around Bali and unwittingly buying herself a seat on the bus ride to crazytown. By the end of episode one, all the wheels have been set in motion. Our four leads have drawn the beginning lines to create four concentric circles which overlap amongst each other. That, my chingus, is a recipe for disaster, or as succinctly put in KorChinGlish, omo crap aiya! [For reference, please see “Book of Recipes for Shit You Never Want to Make”, not yet available on the IPad].
What happened in Bali apparently follows you back to Seoul:
The fated foursome make the connections in Bali that will forever alter their lives. [Man, I’m sure they each wish someone missed a plane, train, green light somewhere, huh?] Then they hightail it back to Seoul for one reason or another.
Once everyone gets back to Seoul, they discover that (here comes the pretzel that’s going to make a Gordian knot): In Wook and Jae Min work at the same company owned by Jae Min’s dad. Soo Jung and In Wook take the same plane back to Seoul. Soo Jung crashes at the apartment of her friend who just so happens to lives next to In Wook. Soo Jung goes to work at the same above-mentioned company to repay the money she borrowed from Jae Min to help bail out her no-good brother. And Young Joo is all “I want a hot sexy So Ji Sub for a boyfriend AND marry a rich buffoon like Jae Min, and this no-nothing girl is starting to look like a genuine threat for my plan for world domination to have my cake and eat it too.”
To everyone’s somewhat surprise, both In Wook and Jae Min start to fall for Soo Jung. And to no one’s surprise, neither guy wants Young Joo.

So there you go, I’ve set up for you the outline of WHIB. Let me use this moment to say that I will go no further in elucidating the plot beyond what I have written so far. Why? Because the plot of WHIB is inconsequential. What I mean is that each event happens in order to facilitate a character to make a choice: Door 1 or Door 2. But the event itself is not important, we can substitute any variety of scenarios that can create an impasse for the character in question. What is vital is that the character MUST make a choice. And that choice is a domino that has a ripple effect, on and on it goes.
Too bad WHIB is not a situational Three’s Company type of slapstick comedy, because I already see the genius in this set-up. Alas, WHIB is as dark as You’re Beautiful is light and airy and fluffy (oooh, I see Lee Hong Ki as a fairy over there!). Rather than the choices in WHIB all leading to happy rainbow-filled places, each choice invariably leads somewhere painful and impossible for a do-over. [One can even argue that each Door 1 and Door 2 contains only bad choices, i.e the drama is built upon a fatalistic premise – I won’t even dare to argue this point in the body of this review, but I will say that I’ve considered the possibility that the deck is stacked with only joker cards].
So what entails is nineteen more episodes of the ever more convoluted foursome simultaneously trying to get what each wants in life, while screwing the other same gender competitor over. It’s impossible to look away. No wonder it’s a fact etched in stone (probably next to that what’s-its-name sword stuck in the same stone) that the ride to crazytown always ends in a giant wreck.
Let’s play a game of musical chairs:
The crucial element in WHIB’s subversion of the Cinderella Story is that these are cookie-cutter K-drama cliche characters behaving in ways K-dramas wouldn’t dare tread.
Jae Min is The Rich Guy. But instead of being an arrogant ass suffering from childhood trauma with a soft center waiting for a kind-hearted maiden to melt his icy exterior, Jae Min is a clown. He has neither the depth to have a soft center nor strong enough to sport a commanding bearing. He’s a thoroughly ordinary, somewhat meaningless man, who happens to have a lot of money.

In Wook is The Poor Guy. But instead of being the hardworking straight shooter, In Wook is a mercenary. He has neither the purity of soul we require of our poor guy attains success story nor the benevolence and resignation to forgive life’s infractions against him. He’s simply a naturally gifted guy, with no connections but an understandable thirst for success and respect.
Young-joo is The Rich Girl. But instead of being a clueless princess desperately clinging on to fairy tales, Young-joo is a realist. She has neither the strength to fight not to sacrifice her happiness for money nor the courage to make the right decisions because she understands the consequences of such decisions. She’s a discerning pampered girl who has knowingly and willingly given up love for security.

And last, but never least, Soo Jung is The Poor Girl. But instead of a humble, shy girl with a heart of gold, Soo Jung is a skeptic. She has neither the temerity to believe she’ll chance upon a Cinderella opportunity nor the teflon exterior required to refuse hopes and dreams when it does fall upon her. When faced with a once-in-a-lifetime choice, she nevertheless struggles at whether to trade a hard-knock life for the possibility of taking an easier journey.
Each of them knows that they have to pay a dear price to get what they want (memo to crazy foursome: there is no such thing as a free ride). But no one truly comprehends how steep the price is to pay when you dare to reach across the aisle and pair up the wrong way. If Rich Guy and Rich Girl fell in love, and Poor Guy and Poor Girl found their happily ever after, then we would have no story to tell.
Alas, Rich Guy wants Poor Girl, Rich Girl wants Poor Guy, then Rich Girl wants Rich Guy when Poor Guy doesn’t want her, Poor Guy wants Poor Girl, and Poor Girl just wants to get her hardworking money back but keeps bumping into Rich Guy, Poor Guy and Rich Girl jostling for power and love (also known as musical love chairs), until Poor Girl becomes the ultimate prize to be won. And then Poor Girl has to decide who (Rich Guy or Poor Guy) and what (security or love) she wants the most. [Btw, Soo Jung may be able to get both security and love from the same guy, so don't think there is only one or the other choice for this little orphaned Poor Girl]. Phew, whose head is spinning with me here? No wonder Soo Jung has this expression.

Cut it with the hyperbole, are you sure I’ve never seen this before?:
Despite the unconventional set-up, the premise of WHIB may still appear rather uninteresting (people can’t be together because of money and social conventions). I grant you that. What is hard to describe in any review are the intangibles. The intangible elements in WHIB happen to all converge at the right place and time, blending together seamlessly to create a memorable drama.
The single most outstanding element of WHIB’s success is the acting. Hands down, the four leads performed like whirling dervishes of desire, hunger, jealousy, hope, regret and despair. Jo In Sung won both the acting award from SBS and the Baeksang for his performance as Jung Jae Min. He created a living, breathing, fully-formed replica of a man who has everything money can buy but only wants the one thing he does not know how to give or receive: love. [And folks, you ain’t ever seen a man “cry” like Jo In Sung does cry in WHIB, I mean, his meltdowns have attained legendary status in the K-drama world – maybe as legendary as Choi Ji Woo’s ability to produce giant rolling perfectly formed tear drops on demand].

So Ji Sub was (slightly) overshadowed by the flamboyance of Jo In Sung’s Jae Min, but In Wook is a deeper, darker character to play. So Ji Sub made In wook a man who has all that money cannot buy (looks and intelligence), but is frustrated by social constraints and wonders if having money can plug whatever is missing in his life.
Ha Ji Won’s Soo Jung is a love or hate type of character (for the record, I like Soo Jung, her decisions, her reactions, her internal conflicts, feel real to me). She represents the embodiment of desire and despair, which makes her unlikeable since most folks prefer our heroines to be relatable and soulfully pure (when people say that Ha Ji Won is like a walking ball of sex, I believe that statement). Though Soo Jung is calculating, she never feels manipulative or trashy. She keeps clawing to get out of needing anyone, but fate keeps jerking her around and into the arms of both men.
Park Ye Jin got stuck with the unfortunate short end of the stick, in that she plays the lone fourth wheel. But she produced a sterling performance as a woman wrestling with tightly coiled anger and bitchiness, used to cloak vulnerability and resentment at her own self-selected imprisonment in a gilded cage.

Love is not just a four-letter word, it might just be a four-letter word that starts with “F” and ends with “k”:
WHIB challenges the long held drama hogwash that love cures all, saves all, conquers all. Much as I like to roll my eyes at such maudlin sentiments, each time a gorgeously constructed K-romance comes along, I happily drink the Kool Aid. [Please, PD sir, may I have some more? - only a few K-romance dramas have earned my ire for being so relentlessly brain dead in plot and chemistry].
But WHIB deconstructs the romance and dares to ask these questions: (1) if two people are in love, will they live happily ever after?, (2) what would a real person do when asked to choose between love or money?, and (3) can falling in love be a person’s downfall rather than the salvation?
Soo Jung is torn between two men, both of whom “love” her (I’ll leave it up to you to discern whether that is even true, and what loving her even means to each of these guys). She can choose Jae Min, who is rich but too weak-willed to fight his family in order to marry her. Or she can choose In Wook, who is smart, but full of calculating ambition while lacking the means to break free from his low-born circumstances.
WHIB has a undisputed leading lady, Ha Ji Won, but no leading man. Both Jae Min and In Wook get equal screen time and interaction with Soo Jung, so you can’t use convention to guess which guy gets the girl. The kissing test also doesn’t work here (you know, the first guy who kisses the girl is almost always the leading man). Everyone kisses the other two persons of the opposite sex, so it’s a melange of trading partners, except its still pretty chaste, so don’t worry about covering the kids’ eyes.

By now are you are probably thinking: “Choose the guy you love, Soo Jung.” Normally I would have been screaming this at the screen. But the relationships in WHIB are knotted so tight, so impossible to extricate, I can safely say that there is no consensus answer as to which guy Soo Jung loves.
I have my interpretation because I picked up on one set of cues. On a subsequent re-watch of WHIB, I picked up on another set of cues. WHIB is a masterful manipulator of human interaction, and creates a Rorschach-like tableau where you see what you want to see. Poor Girl loves Rich Guy or Poor Guy depending on whether YOU would pick Rich Guy or Poor Guy (trust me, it’s a reflection of our own experience and prejudices).
Oh yeah, there is all that other stuff:
Much as I want to keep talking about Jo In Sung crying or Ha Ji Won driving men mad, I should devote a few sentences to other things that might interest you. The screenwriter of WHIB should be commended for writing a barebones story (four people keep running into each other and lo and behold, complications of the heart [and other lower regions] arise) in a compelling way.
All the Cinderella clichés are employed: the awkward first meet, the misunderstanding, the initial dislike, the fated to keep running into each other, the unwitting attraction, the disparate circumstances, the disapproving parents, the third wheel that wants to break the couple up, and so on and so forth.
Except in WHIB, Soo Jung pretty much has the exact same Cinderella experience with BOTH guys. Prince Charming doesn’t necessary mean the rich guy, it could also mean the good-looking smart guy with a promising future, i.e. I believe the term should be applied to a guy that is considered a “great catch”, whatever that means. Both Jae Min and In Wook are quite possibly Soo Jung’s Prince Charming.
So fate plays a twisted joke on our girl. How’s a girl supposed to pick a guy when she can’t go by the Cinderella playbook. No wonder poor Soo Jung is so confused and torn, and literally drives both guys into varying states of insanity (or groiny discomfort, which I profess to know nothing about).

The PD of WHIB was competent, providing a steady and uncomplicated hand in framing the scenes. WHIB is all about the acting, so while the background has a very ordinary feel, you hardly notice it because your eyes can’t leave the death or desire glares that each of the four leads keeps shooting at one another. [Seriously, some of the most awesome scenes are the ones when all four leads are interacting at the same time, I’m all like “eeeek, omo, please drama god or PD, pour some mud in that room and all that tension will be released through a nice bout of wrestling”].
Sadly, most of the scenes in Bali fail to elicit any of the culture or tropical feel of the lush setting (and no, having everyone either go swimming and/or fall into the swimming pool doesn’t count – but see the sexy below anyways). Which is a shame, but has no negative effect on the drama as a whole. Bali represents either heaven or a haven, and it’s that metaphorical representation of Bali that is crucial to this story, and not capturing the dreamy mood of Bali is regrettable but not a dealbreaker.

While the PD isn’t going to win any awards for the directing in WHIB, he nevertheless keeps the drama moving at a very steady pace. Watching WHIB is like watching someone wring a towel. Each wring more water is excised, the towel is knotted tighter, and the pressure builds. As our four hapless leads spin around and around into each other’s orbit, colliding at odd times and ever more uncomfortable situations, the tension grows thicker and thicker, and pretty soon you can cut it with a knife. The PD effectively allows the tension to accumulate by keeping the scenes and setting simple and spare.
There are no fancy cars, pretty McMansions, and cute outfits to distract us. While some of Jae Min’s outfits were the opposite of cute, and would have made me cringe (except for the fact that I had watched Goong by then and after Prince Shin’s outfits, nothing ever seemed so cringeworthy anymore), it did have an ulterior purpose of showing his character to be part buffoon and part playboy.
In Wook could use a new hairstyle, but So Ji Sub managed to exude charisma despite wearing a broom weave on his head. The ladies wear the fashion befitting their station in life: Young Joo is all haughty-bitch Chanel and Soo Jung is all working-girl Fashion 21. If you want a pretty-to-look-at drama, sorry, WHIB Is not pretty in the least. On the other hand, the dullness of the visuals is counterbalanced by the actors in WHIB, who are collectively too pretty for words.
The soundtrack is suitable and appropriate at setting the mood, yet wholly forgettable. You’re not going to log on and download the music anytime soon. But you will not likely forget many key scenes in the drama even as time dims the memory of what the actors were wearing or where they were standing. What’s best about the directing and music in WHIB is that it never overwhelms a scene or overshadows the acting (Paradise ain’t touching this with a ten-foot pole). And sometimes that is to be commended, to be un-obstructionist and just allow your fantastic actors to command the screen and deliver the goods, in all its poker face and/or fist-in-mouth-angsty glory.
The ending (this is what you came here for, right?):
So, I’ve finally reached the good stuff, didn’t I? Sorry for making you wade through all the melo and all the drama to get to The Ending To End All Endings. Heh, that was a tad dramatic. But it wouldn’t be too far off for me to surmise that some (many) of you have heard whispers in the night about the ending of WHIB. So you’re curious, what could be so Dramatic and Shocking that people who have watched WHIB will only tell you that its Dramatic and Shocking but refuse to elaborate. Maybe it’s because we’re just mean like that.
Or really it’s because knowing the ending of WHIB without watching the drama has no impact. So no one wants to give it away. I don’t find WHIB’s ending in any way, shape, or form something like the end of The Crying Game or the end of The Sixth Sense (shocking for the sake of shocking).
WHIB’s ending is impactful because, up until the very end, you really have no clue how it will all end. Really, how many times have you watched a drama, and from the very first frame you know how it was going to end? Yeah, pretty much all the time. So here is a drama that is twisty, turny, angsty and has a cannot-be-100%-guessed ending. So why would we want to ruin it for you? And why would you want to ruin it for yourself? Don’t go Google it, please, I beg of you.

I personally was satisfied with the ending. Well, okay, that’s stretching the truth a little. After the final frame ended, first I sat dumbstruck for about ten minutes, then I screamed at my computer screen, then I called my poor sister and screamed at her for no reason (and probably ruined any desire for her to ever watch WHIB, I is a bad bad sister, I know), then I rolled around the floor like a himono onna and scared the bejesus out of my entire befuddled family, and then finally, finally, after many many weeks, I came to realization that the ending was just right. Not too hot, not too cold, but just right.
I did not feel the ending came out of left field or was a giant WTF moment. I mentioned how WHIB as a drama continues to build the tension, and like a balloon being pumped full of too much air, the ending of WHIB was inevitable. Except for at the very beginning, when any one of the four players could have said “time out, I don’t want to play this game anymore.” Once they started intruding into each other’s lives, there was only one way for this drama to end. And kudos to WHIB for having the balls to end it that way.
A look at WHIB from a big picture perspective:
What’s shocking for me was that WHIB’s ending broke the 30% mark in ratings, and during its entire run the ratings averaged in the mid-to-late twenties. I cannot imagine how ahjummas and veteran drama watchers alike would countenance this sacrilege of their K-drama conventions, and yet it appeared that I am the close-minded one. WHIB was widely considered a success, both critically and ratings-wise.

The public was indeed ready to dismantle some of its tried and true beliefs that love can overcome all obstacles. And to confront the scary possibility that “What if love is the obstacle?” I wonder if everyone would have been much happier had they stayed in their respective roles rather than falling in love and sinking the House of Sand (or an even better analogy would be the game of Jenga, for those who have not played it, the rules are players take turns to remove a block from a tower and balance it on top, creating a taller and increasingly unstable structure as the game progresses, and one mistaken pull, the entire tower crumbles).
WHIB tackled the dark side of the themes of love, desire, money, and power, and did so in a way that had me riveted to the screen. When I finished WHIB, I immediately re-watched it again. Right away. My mind and heart was so absorbed by these characters and their maddening situation. The funny thing is, on my second watch, I went from shipping one male lead to shipping the other male lead. But I stand firm in my own conclusion that while Soo Jung liked both men, she ultimately only loved one of them. Which is why the ending is so epic and yet so “I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter.”

While the public may have embraced the deconstruction of the Cinderella Story, part of me wonders if they really got to the deep, tortured heart of why money, riches, pure hearts, transformed souls, all of that may not be enough to overcome the tragedy wrought by the weakness in human nature.
After WHIB, Jo In Sung and Ha Ji Won become a CM darling couple (and I for one loved their CMs, they definitely have chemistry to spare).

But it rather negated the take home lesson of WHIB. If even after WHIB, all the public wanted was to see this toxic couple, who granted lit up the screen, re-enact the public couple dance that many classic K-drama couplings did, then this coupling was no different than the publicly lauded golden couples in Winter Sonata or Beautiful Days.
So this was a destructive relationship, and yet we swoon over them in real life? Eh, I’m one of those lemmings, so I am merely pondering the possibility that the conventions were upended but ultimately the lesson not learned. And the Ha Ji Won/So Ji Sub pairing was no less toxic, just less flamboyant and splashy.
Even though WHIB takes a chainsaw to K-drama Cinderella clichés, it delivered the message firmly within the construct of a K-drama. You can deconstruct and challenge a subject matter, but it needs to be done in a way that engages the viewer, and WHIB does this. Each episode ends with the requisite humdinger of a cliffhanger or the pause right before The Big Dramatic Moment. There are no shortage of drinking at street stalls, the stretching of possibility type coincidences, getting piggybacked drunk, fistfights between our leading men, bitch showdowns between our leading women, and some seriously carnal moments of tension-filled will-they-or-won’t-they suspense.

Even the sidekicks get in on the act. Jae Min’s parents are responsible for some of the most unforgettable acts of K-drama parental beatdown on the youngsters I have ever witnessed. [Speaking of Jae Min's parents, never have I seen actors playing the parents and sibling of a handsome leading actor/actress look so MONUMENTALLY different than said lead - Jae Min's parents and brother are like Orcs who sired a Human, part of me kept waiting for the "You're adopted!!" shoe to fall, but alas, that twist is but a figment of my imagination].
How can something so messed up be so good?:
WHIB is drama of the most exquisite torturous kind. I felt emotionally dirty afterwards. Then took a long hard look at my own life, and let out a giant breath of relief. Whew, man, for once am I glad to be me. Normally we all wish to be a Shin Chae Kyung (who gets plucked from her commoner life and becomes a princess married to a rock and pursued by a block of wood) or a Geum Jan Di (who goes from being a commoner to the object of desire for an adorably socially inept rich boy with a perm and a block of wood for a “soulmate”).
No one, I repeat, no one, will want to be any of the four characters in WHIB. Because these characters are so real in their flaws and their desires, it shatters the illusion that being any one of them would magically make us happy. [I like my illusions, most days I dream that I am sitting on the beach in New Caledonia watching My I Lub You, Junki and Lee Min Ho swimming and smiling at me, and taking turns bringing me juice].
But its worth watching WHIB to remind us that sometimes meeting a rich guy may not be a good thing, and being pretty can bring more trials than rewards. WHIB is a hard drama to swallow, but its memorable and addicting. It’s not the best thing I’ve ever watched, but it sure as heck is hard to forget. [Also, these two guys are so hot and bothered in this drama, no one would blink an eye if you watch it purely for the eye candy.]

The above is simply my personal feelings towards WHIB. I almost never recommend WHIB, because I think the viewer has to be in the mood for such a drama, and has the constitution for darker fare. WHIB is a drama you hate to love (does that make me a masochist?) or love to hate (does that make me ninny?). And both sets of feelings are completely acceptable, because WHIB speaks to the parts inside each of us we’d rather not acknowledge exists.
Until next time, thanks for (once again) taking the time to read my ponderings on K-dramas. It’s been so much fun writing about WHIB, I’m (almost) tempted to watch it again. Almost, but not quite, because dang it, first I have to go take a cold shower.
[A quick note of warning: I've tried my best to keep this review spoiler-free, but WHIB is such a meaty drama that a meaningful discussion does necessitate talking about what happened and why. I have no doubt I'll be letting loose my inner freak MUN-trained debate skillz in the comments section below to really do a deep dive into this drama. For those of you who have not yet watched WHIB, I suggest you skip the comments and come back afterwards to read them if you're in the mood for moar moar WHIB]






I never thought I’d ever watch or ever even like a K-drama where love is so toxic and twisted.After watching WHIB, all I could think of was that love would have been so simple if it was more like math where 1+1 is only equal to 2.I’ve never seen a K-drama where I kept shifting my sympathies from one character to the next till in the end it was definitely a WTF moment.And I really liked the fact that the writer gave the characters flaws that were so real and didn’t give them enough redeeming qualities to make them into the typical leads of K-dramas.
Jo In-sung’s acting was such revelation.I couldn’t believe my eyes that this was the same guy who was so wooden and expressionless in “The Classic”.His acting draws you into the drama and makes you sympathise with him even though he is so spineless and callous.And man,this guy can cry and it is just so gut wrenching to watch the scenes where he breaks down.
As for So Ji-sub,I think I need to watch some other drama/movie of his to make me like him.( looks like MISA is there on the horizon) I just wanted to shake some sense into In-wook and most of the time he looked as if he had stones in his mouth which was why he couldn’t just spit out what he really wanted to say.Loved the ladies-Ha Ji-won and Park Ye-jin were both just brilliant and the scenes of them together were just crackling with tension.
@Taohua -I think Jo In-sung here looks a lot like JGS in ‘The Happy Life’ that I swear they could almost be brothers:-) *goes back to googling movies and dramas to get her Jo In-sung fix*
i heard of this drama but never bother about it.
But like 1 year+ ago, i started to get interested in it and start to find reviews on this drama.
Most of the reviews i read are complains of the ending.
And i go and watch the ending and it wow me.
i decided to watch this drama due to a lot good reviews on this drama and it’s rating is good.
But i can’t survive the first minute.
After reading your review,i feel like watching the drama again.
woah .This drama is so powerful i say. I love it. I love everything about it. The casting was excellent and the writer is definitely brilliant. This isn’t your ordinary drama. Agree?..err- if you noticed, there are scenes taken in Bali that didn’t appeared on WHIB..?.. RIGHT?..I did not notice the pic above..the one showing Young-joo and Kang In-wook under a mini waterfall..
Sorry, Sorry, chingus. I read all your comments (nomnomnomnom, ockoala powaaaaa shuju), but haven’t had a chance to respond til now.
@ esteel – I’m so excited to hear what you think about WHIB, looking forward to hearing back from you!
@ cille – yay for using my review as bait, hope you can reel in a few drama-loving friends to check this out.
@ Ana (comment 1 and 2) – wow, you really did watch all of WHIB! I’m glad you liked it, and that JIS has now made a super impact on you. I also went to watch of bunch of his other works after I saw WHIB. He’s not my fave actor, but his performance in WHIB deserves to be immortalized. If you liked what he did in WHIB, he pretty much played the same character again in Spring Days (with Go Hyun-jung and Ji Jin-hee). Spring Days is a remake of the J-drama Heaven’s Coins (the J-drama is much better).
@ jayjay – thanks for the lovely comment, letting me know you enjoyed my review. I suggest you work up the courage to rewatch WHIB, you may really pick up nuances that wasn’t as apparent the first time around. I sure did. And JIS’s performance is even cooler the second time around.
@ jh – WHIB is one of my top 5 dramas as well (I don’t know how long it’ll stay there, but it’s looking mighty comfortable right now).
@ sam – thanks for enjoying the review, it was hard finding screencaps for WHIB because it’s an older drama, and fist-in-mouth needs to be witnessed firsthand and not just looking at a screencap so I elected not to include it. But it’s pretty mantastic, no?
@ bee – WHIB is a slow burn, it builds and builds the relationships and the entanglements. Some folks really don’t like it, it just isn’t their cup of tea, which I totally get. Let me know if you try it out again, and what you think.
@ Bu Li Lit – heh, yeah, this drama is excellent writing and acting, no doubt about it. The pick of SJS and PYJ under the waterfall was not in the drama and was probably shot for publicity photos. But I had to include it, so pretty, don’t you think?
Hey, I’m new to your blog & I love it! Your review on WHIB is epic!
I remember, as soon as I saw the first episode, I was 100% hooked. I mean, JIS in bed w/ another woman, SJS half-naked, sweating, doing push-ups in the middle of Bali… hell-yeah that’s my kinda drama!! xDD
But all the shallowness aside, I absolutely enjoyed all the deep, dark, dirty, screwed-up issues that the series explored. Like you mentoined, it makes you re-check your own perspectives. There is no way I would’ve wanted to be anyone of these people (well, maybe Ha Ji Won, just for a day, only to see how it would feel to be pure sex on legs^^;;)
So WHO does Soo Jung truly love? I like to tell myself Jae Min but in truth, this question will always remain a back & forth puzzler for me. For true happiness, is it better off to be w/ someone who loves you more than you love them? Or do you want to be w/ the one you love the most but they may not necessarily return your love to the same capacity?? This line bwtn the feelings from your heart & the thoughts from your head is so often blurred, just like the line btwn what’s right & wrong. Does there ultimately have to be the ONE right answer? Probably not. But whichever path you choose you have to live w/ the consequences that may come along w/ it.
BTW, I actually disagree w/ you on the soundtrack. I loved it. Remember, My Love, That’s Love & The Way… they all had me humming & moving. I think they really captured the setting & the emotions of the series (for example, listening to The Way makes me me wanna get some jet-ski action happening in some exotic country & then down a few cocktails afterwards lol)
Normally we all wish to be a Shin Chae Kyung (who gets plucked from her commoner life and becomes a princess married to a rock and pursued by a block of wood) or a Geum Jan Di (who goes from being a commoner to the object of desire for an adorably socially inept rich boy with a perm and a block of wood for a “soulmate”)^^ A princess & heir to the Queen throne, w/ a certain Prince Shin‘s back to hug all night long?? YES puhleease. But being an overtly loud, obnoxious girl turned weepy, no-sense-of-self, wailing mess who toyed w/ the heart of my dear JiHoo sunbae?? Heck-to-the-no!
Anyways, sorry if I rambled a smidgen (it’s an innate gift lol) but mind if I link you to my blogroll? ^_^
Bravo…..fantastic review!!!!
I watched WHIB a long time back and afterwards read about it in some forum & they all said that the ending sucks. I don’t agree at all coz it has to end like that, ppl!!!! How else are the characters to end up? They are too entangled in that messy web to have a fairy tale ending……aaaarrgghhhh!!!!!(reminds me of Damo…..huuhu, where’s my tissue)
Wow….I’m sooooo glad I stumbled upon yr blog and found this. Finally, someone that looks at this drama realistically.
Duh! It’s only taken me what 3 and a half weeks to come back here and find out I need to learn to look again, SO so sorry Ockoala! I must find the mood to watch this this summer. Still truly impressed with the writing even reading second time around. Thank you so much for putting so much into this Ockoala!
ockoala: i see.. so those photos are meant for its promotion..yeah those pics are
)
beautiful..i feel like watching it again. haha. cheers!
hey..does anyone knw whther there will be a sequel to this fantastic heart-wrenching drama???
I want to know the sequel too
i dont think there’ll be a sequel..i mean the story ended right there..i wanna know see the other characters’ reaction though the moment they heard the news that jae min killed kang in wook and soo jung and committed suicide after.. i wonder how jae min’s family, young joo, mi hee, in wook’s mom and soo jung’s brother dealt with that. hmmnn.. i feel like watching it again..and ive been watching the last ep wenever i miss it. haha.
there wouldnt be much of a show then b li lit…i heard they remake the drama n its called somthng lk Tokyo blah blah blah..not sure though it..but I assure you no one can be more crazy over this drama than me..i watched this for the fst time in 2004 and I could not resist not buying the full DVD set since then I have watched it for like the hundreth time n Im not kidding…..all of them are just so superb..both in looks and acting -wise. Jo In sung really impressed us all with his acting though I do find his crying a bit over the top and unmanly at times. I think if he has more gut in him to defy his family and put everything behind for the woman he loves with all his life, and SJ more faith in love, both would have a happy ending.
@amy.l: oh?!!..ill watch out for that something blah blah in tokyo..is it a japanese adaptation of WHIB??..oh yeah..cheers to that. this series rocked our world. yeah.
BLL : nope..heard its the same cast and plot..I guess they gonna change the ending abit because I don’t think the ending is satisfactory.Maybe they will start the first episode with both JM and SJ already married to each other…lol,,but this is indeed an imagination of mine I don’t think that will happen no matter how many hardcore fans of this drama insist on one such continuation. Anyway, just keep your eyes open for the sequel (if there is any)
@amy.l: haha. now dats an imagination. hmmnn..i keep on wondering what cud’ve been if JM & SJ really got married in the end. seeesh. yeah im gonna keep my eyes open of course. >:))
Hi amy.l and bu li lit:
Just to dispel the rumor (wonder where it got started?) – there is NO sequel (or even remake) or WHIB. Never was, and definitely never will be using the same cast.
If SBS considered a sequel or remake, that would have been years ago after WHIB first ended, but clearly never materialized.
Three of the 4 leads are HUGE movie stars in Korea now, and Jo In Sung and Ha Ji Won hasn’t made a drama in 4 years. Jo In Sung is now doing his mandatory army service, and So Ji Sub finished his and is back acting in dramas and movies.
But let’s put this random rumor to rest and never speak of it again.
… a sequel? A Movie… this drama cannot be duplicated.. those who think they can are making a mistake… Just don’t waste your money whoever you are…. This stellar drama with a truly stellar cast is one in a million and truly cannot ever be duplicated!!!
@ockoala : ok. thanks for clearing things up. i was thinking the same too. how cud there be a sequel wen it ended ryt there. ryt? ..oh well. well. well. a WHIB THE MOVIE is much more possible. wat do u think?..
)
Yayyyy…. it is the best suggestion… with the same casts of course… hopely there were good producer and director out there reading your post…. since, Jo In Sung did not taking a role in small screen since WHIB…. sigh…
The review is totally amazing, so detailed and so insightful. I wonder how many times the reviewermust have watched this drama before completing the review? I watched this drama about two years ago in my old country Burma, with Burmese subtitles. At first I thought it would be just a light, romantic comedy, but then the plot becomes darker and murkier, and finally when the ending comes with a bang I was so shell-shocked and I couldn’t believe it! But I started praising the Korean director for having the guts to kill all three main characters as the only way to end this story plausibly. This must be the first in any drama, where three out of four main leads got bumped off. I was really sad to hear SJ’s deathbed declaration of love, which must have pushed JM over the edge. If I can bear to watch the last episode, I must rewatch this drama again with English subs as I think the Burmese subs are not that reliable. Thank you for the review and all the comments that give different interpretations to the question who SJ does really love, and how the four characters manage to mess up each other’s life.
I can smell manipulation from miles afar but I went long for the ride ;part curiosity ,part knock-me-dead -acting ,part depravity (mine and theirs , to do a comparison , a major theme explored here ). Nobody ever complained WHIBali to be an uncompelling watch but even so, it is not easy on us .The plot is contrived (they all end up running into each other all the time !),the characters are drawn unsympathetically ,situations seem repetitive and even pointless at times ,an Anti-Drama , if you will .It’s like the writer decided ,I am going to write about four ill-fated characters caught in vicious ,intense ,claustrophobic hate and something resembling love (you could have fooled me !) and throw it out !……now ,that’s brilliant ,leaving it to the audience for interpretation .Everyone saw what they wanted to see , you brought in your personal beliefs into it.The passionate ones could see the true love between J & S, feeling justified in their shipping , the intelligent could see the sanity of In-wook but the ordinary viewers (where the majority would fall ) just saw a messed up unordinary love story with great acting talents .
Since multiple dissertations on inverted Classic Cinderella story has been done to death with WHIBali,I propose a new thought:I propose the unknowing but true villain here is Su-jong .She comes in doe -eyed ,honest in her greed but never in her desires . She is reasonably intelligent , hardworking and trustworthy ,I’m not disputing that but though she is praised as being smart despite her not completing education ; her lack of character ,depth ,education shows in the choices she made or rather she didn’t make .I would say she even encouraged her brother to be a liability. I am not saying she should have chosen In- wook over Jae-min ,I am saying it was beyond her to choose In-wook , so her falling in love with Jae-min makes sense from the beginning .As thundie said ; She is that easy with him because she is in love and because she is by nature “easy” and I like her for that .I am okay with her walking away from both of them , I am okay with her choosing either one of them , but her lack of constancy stems from lack of security and self-worth but once adults, we cannot have others make choices for us and in the process ,she destroyed both men …..Ha Ji Won looks utterly innocent and conniving at the same time ,only a brilliant actor can attract and repulse you at the same time and she’s all that and more .
Since children we are told to be happy , every step we take is planned to secure that coveted happiness in life.The mantra goes ‘ as long as you are happy …whatever makes you happy ….’. Intertwined with this happiness game is Love. We are constantly looking for meaning in rather uneventful things , that elusive fateful encounter ,yearning to start our own story.We are laughable in thinking love is uncalculated ; we are engineered to be calculating ,to look out for self,so in that sense ,Jae-min is the most pitiful character ,he couldn’t ultimately secure his happiness despite all the money and a girl who actually fell in love with him and whom he loved .All said and done ,I see infinite possibilities in the character of Jae-min .Money ,status ,connections,power ;people born into this are taught to maintain the status quo,I understand that , but he was saveable inspite of all that unlike Young-joo. Jo In-sung played once-in-lifetime role with no holding back .It takes a gutsy actor to lose oneself. So Ji-sup’s In-wook is an intelligent man unwittingly drawn to their games and on a sanity level ,he seems the most relatable amongst the four. But then again ,I am blinded by So Ji-sup and anything I say further will be my bias talking
The ultimate brilliance of WHIB’s story is the ending , not in the deaths ,which was overdue but in the confession .Cheating or not ,it made us literally go back to every single scene of the drama to ‘see’ what we failed to see the first time , in the short span of time she was shot till she died. Because i t’s at that point I fell in love with them , my wary ,held-back thoughts thrown away in mad turbulence of tragic love . Now ,that is how you tell a suspenseful mystery
ALERT!!! SPOILERS AHEAD!!!–Awesome take–Sujong as the villain, you know when I first watched WHIB–I was beyond confused as to who to root for. I mean the writers were so great at concealing–was it concealing? or just simply manipulating vieweres like me–an emotional person, to easily get drawn into the web of WHIB. I truly thought Sujong initially as the villain not the victim… My initial thought was that Young Joo would be the heroine but UHHH–who manipulated who!!! Really, really…I truly admired Jo In Sung (no matter what he does, he’ll do no wrong as an actor to me–sooo biased!!) but I too shipped So Ji Sub’s In Wook. My husband fell in love with Ha Ji Won… Yeah, this drama made me a fan of Ha Ji Won… I’ve already posted beyond here, it was my first post in this blog then I saw your post, I had to add to your view. This is my second post today because I can never stop my admiration for this drama and the actors who made this such a thrill ride with more ups and downs than a roller coaster ride. Again, this truly is a worhtwhile drama that would be great to marathon because, you won’t be able to wait for the ending…… that’s for those who have not watched yet!!! Enjoy!!!???
I don’t know why you had to insult some viewers by distinguishing between “intelligent ones” and the “ordinary.”
….*went along for the ride *. I need an editor to proofread everything I write
came across this entry while looking for WHIB sypnosis. But apparently, I opened wikipedia at the same time and read that first (followed by yours)
I’m having this secret garden fever so that’s y i’m considering watching Ha Ji Won’s dramas and definitely i’m not gonna watch this coz I’ve just screamed and called my friend right after finished reading the things they put on wiki for WHIB.
omg, this drama is crazy!
Yup… WHIB was the first drama to lead me BACK to watch Kdrama started since 2 years ago. I remember watching endless love and some other kdramas during my school time (years ago hehehhe) that were broadcasting in the country. When WHIB was aired, I already had set my mind to not see any Kdrama again. They were entertaining for sure but I found them to be so unrealistic. So I missed WHIB.
Since the title has Bali in it, I like Bali, and I still remember how some of my friends were soo enthusiastic to see it but at the end rejected the ending. Hahahhahaha…. I did not know how can this drama create such a fussy…
Yeah, one day i decided to see it through streaming line. No one was around, only me in my dorm university room and my computer screen and no one to discuss about it since all my friend was (probably) busy studying. I could not bring my self to stop from rally watching it in three consecutive days. I did not remember how I can survive sitting for lectures but my mind was not there with dark cycle around my eyes…. Hahahhaha…. then the final ep ended… I was blown away of shock… I did not remember anymore for how long, but yeah I was heavily having this deep shock.
Anyway, I started to watch Kdrama ever since again, but WHIB is one of the some best out there after many years of hallyu wave spread through Asia and now Europea. Today drama mostly have comical side in the story…but nothing like WHIB anymore… somehow its good, I mean, wathing all those comical or halfcomical kdramas can erased the heavily shock in me because WHIB….
Thundie and Ockoala… I am so looost in both your blogsites, I just found them yesterday courtesy of a soompi forum member regarding Lie to Me recaps…. So now I find myself in the recap for one of my all time favorite What Happened in Bali (etc titles..) Wow, you guys have it!! I had asked JB (of Dramabeans) if she had ever thought of recapping older dramas most especially this WHIB… Of course, she responded that it was one of her hope-to-do but too busy… So now to my happy surprise is this recap.. Yahoo…!!! This drama is one of the BEST EVER!!! Like many, I decided to one day just browse the net on Veoh… At that time. WHIB was still part of the line up but the last few episoes were missing!! How dare Veoh drop those last episodes.. Of course, I had to drive an hour away to Chinatown to get any copy I could get my hands on of WHIB!!! I had my husband marathon this with me, he had patience, I did not. So anyway, found that copy and the ending.. I totally agree with the writer that ending is sooo acceptable. It’s the one and only ending for such a hypnotic drama… If only those who have watched it accepted the ending, I bet this Kdrama would be part of the top videos/dramas in the world.. So off with my rants…
WHIB, I so loved Jo In Sung, So Ji Sub and Ha Ji Won in this…… I wavered so much as to who should have ended up with who in the love triangle.. Jo In Sung–because of WHIB am a religious follower/fan–he was so beyond awesome in this drama. He was the AMAZING in this drama. So Ji Sub–I didn’t know whether to call him a jerk or a saint–SJS was awesome here too. Poor Ha Ji Won–I’d have been like her if this happened to me!!! At your wits end, yes MONEY makes the world go round sometimes a far, far second to LOVE!!! True, true this is no child’s play, this is an adult story that while I watched, the story line and the acting were so overwhelmingly real that I had to pause and sit a while just to take everything in. When really think about it, it was the whole ensemble that made this such a great drama… It needs to be shared around the world. The ending, I truly believe that is the one and only was it had to end. Such powerful emotions arose from watching this worthwhile drama, I felt so drained but I hope everyone will watch with an open mind and accept how it ends. WHIB is truly a MUST WATCH drama, you cannot call yourself a Kdrama addict if you have not watched this!!!! Thanks for the great site and space.
Hallo Thundie and Ockoala…. and for all the comments from all of you… many-many thanx. This one also one of the top best drama for me, tho after years with huge number of kdrama was aired out there, could not agree more than all the comments from you that indeed it is one of the best kdrama ever.
The movie from your youtube link is in my laptop screen right now… I still fell the sadness of WHIB by listening to this OST song….. otoke………… taking a short heavy breath…..
Hi. Thanks so much for this review. I thought I would never ever watch Bali again for the rest of my life because of the pain it gave me. I can not believe i watched the entire episode with my then boyfriend night after night. I recommend it to friends (who hated it as well) along with this post. Thanks again.
Thank you for recapping this Drama! I heard of this drama many years ago, started to watch the first episode just because it has Bali as the title (I’m an Indonesia living in US), somehow I got distracted by other dramas that come out recently.. While waiting for the next episode of the other dramas to come out, I decided to continue watching this one… oh my…I cannot believe how I got sucked up into this. The ending is not to my liking (I just want happy ending) but I agree with you this is a good ending to a very complex situation.
Thanks again for your effort! Truly appreciated.
I’m start watching this drama for So Ji SUb this year after watching him in MISA (yes I’m late, I’m start watching both drama this year , sue me) And BALI ! INdonesia … my country….. I’m so glad they choose Bali and include it in tittles…. Got me goosebump when SO Ji SUb and HA JI WOn speak Indonesian language…
This drama is so addicting! Once you start the 1st episode, you can’t help but keep watching and then You realize you can’t sleep, eat, and keep coming back until you watch the last episode… It’s that addicting to me…
Thanks for your insightful review… Thundie…
The first time I watched it, I Ship In Wook the whole time!… I always look a drama in his point of view, because I’m dig his character. I screamed when I first watched the ending, though I know the ending * I had been spoiled*, I didn’t know the conversation before that… It broke my heart when Soo Jung confess the one she love is actually Jae Min. Because like serendipity, I really though she Love In WOok, the way she look at her, her reaction when meet him, a sign she loved him..
The second time, I spent more time to look deeper Soo Jung’s character… I become curious what He sees in Jae Min other than money and power that make her love him? I just can’t accept it.
But when I look her character deeper, all of sudden, I see my self in her! I have experienced love two man at same time in my life… Once is a man a can reached, The man I could lean on, and the other man is a man I couldn’t reached because our gap . And the funny thing is the one that scratch in my heart until now is the one I can’t reached back then. Until now, I still feel the love for him though I’m no longer loving that guy… The second time I wacth WHIB, that’s when I can relate and feel Soo Jung more… Kudos to the writers…